Monday, March 03, 2008

Dr. Helen reports on why homeschooled boys do well with reading

Historically boys have been readers. All the Hardy Boys and Tom Swifts were not read by girls. But over the last couple decades there has been a noticeable decline in the percentage of boys who read.

Alert Dr. Helen found a good article which explains part of the problem: public schools tend to have books more interesting for girls. Over time boys in public schools just tune out.

The problem is with how public schools are run, not with boys. The article explains:

------------------
Educational consultant Joe Manthey, who led a workshop through the Napa County Office of Education about educating male students, cites the almost nonexistent gender gap for home-schooled students in English as proof that schools are part of the problem.
The reason that home-schooled boys score as well as their female counterparts in English is twofold, said Manthey. First, they are more likely to be given a choice in their reading material. Second, “they’re less likely to fall through the cracks,” he said.
Manthey’s research shows that boys are more inclined to read nonfiction than fiction, and are more likely to relate to subjects related to science, sports and stories that revolve around male characters.
“Then you see boys required to read books like ‘The Joy Luck Club,’” he said, referring to the book by Amy Tan about immigrant mothers and daughters.
It’s no wonder, said Manthey, that boys tune out in English class.
------------------

If you have a son in a public school who is struggling with reading, consider homeschooling. He could learn to love reading.


---------
Technorati tags: homeschooling, homeschool, home school, home education, parenting, children, public school, public education, education

8 comments:

Charity said...

A while back, there was an article in our local paper about this. When the reporter asked a local librarian if the library would consider having a program that focused on literacy and boys, featuring books that boys would be interested in, and she said no, that it would not be fair to the girls!

Yet, the city has lots of "girls only" programs, especially in sports.

Everything for boys has to be co-ed.

I am so glad that I homeschool my boys now.

Ann'Re said...

It's not just in the public schools where this is a problem. My 8 YO son is an avid reader and I have a hard time finding good books for in all the popular book stores...yet there is an abundance of books geared toward girls. It gets frustrating. I find the best selection for him at used bookstores, yard sales or half.com.

Alyssa Rock said...

I take it you've heard this news?

http://worldnetdaily.com/index.php?fa=PAGE.view&pageId=57679

Alyssa Rock said...

Bah... stupid comments... Here it is in link form:

California judge orders homeschoolers into government education

Sebastian said...

I noticed this at a big discount store last year. They were selling boxed sets of books. There was a non-specific set and a girl's set.
I also think that the non-fiction section is allowed to get older than the fiction section in a library.

Happy Elf Mom (Christine) said...

My boys enjoy Flat Stanley and that has a LOT of tie-ins. We write letters (English) and send our paper Stanleys to have adventures with faraway friends (geography and social studies).

I learned about Flat Stanley when my older children were in public school.

Maybe because the only girl I have is an infant, I'm out of touch with the disparity. Blissfully ignorant is more like. I had no idea boys would be behind once they got a bit older. I thought they just developed a tad later.

:]

Happy Elf Mom (Christine) said...

PS Interested in hearing your take on the California case as well.

Henry Cate said...

Alyssa, thank you for the pointer.

I'm still coming up to speed on just what the judge's ruling means.